Advertisement

Zoning board passes first ADU case, grapples with procedural questions

The Zoning Board of Appeals this week heard a case about an accessory dwelling unit for the first time since the city overhauled its regulations on the subject last year.

Joseph M. Guigno Jr. of Graymore Road asked for permissions necessary to replace his detached garage with an extension to his single-family home. He wants to create space for his son’s family to live with them. The Building Department had determined that this addition would count as an ADU because of its use and design.

The board unanimously granted Guigno permission to build the ADU larger than code permits and closer than the standard distance from one of its side lot lines.

Guigno’s lawyer, Bret Francis, said the city calculates an ADU’s maximum size by the square footage of the house already existing on a lot, and argued the size of the addition was limited by the fact the existing house was only one story tall. The proposed addition would still be just over 100 square feet above the citywide ADU maximum.

Francis also pointed out that since the property was on a corner lot, the local zoning laws treated one side of the house as an additional front lawn and so required additional distance from the road. 

Kathleen B. McMenimen addresses city council members prior to her appointment to the ZBA, Photo by Artie Kronenfeld.

Associate member Kathy McMenimen expressed reservations that this case could set a precedent for future ADU cases. Both Francis and McMenimen’s fellow board members, however, pushed back strongly on that idea, emphasizing that ZBA decisions are made on a case-by-case basis and cannot be cited in future cases. McMenimen initially asked that the case be sent to the Law Department for review, but eventually retracted that request.

Board member Glenna Gelineau also emphasized the board was “not there to set precedent,” adding that the proposed change wouldn’t be unusual or disruptive to the neighborhood. She commended the Guigno family for proposing a relatively constrained plan, adding that it can be difficult to build in Waltham on a corner lot.

Gelineau added that cases like this, where petitioners proposed new or expanded living solutions on existing lots, were likely going to get more and more common, given the state of land and housing availability in the Boston area. “This is the future, right?” she said.

Friction on meeting procedures

The board also struggled to figure out how to address a series of requests from McMenimen about board rules going forward.

McMenimen made formal requests for the board to review its own internal regulations, change how it distributes case documents to its members, and meet with the Law Department to discuss how its powers and responsibilities have changed in response to significant statewide zoning changes passed this summer.

Advertisement

The board agreed to book a meeting directly with the Law Department to review the new zoning legislation. Chair John Sergi added that the department had already announced it would organize such a session, but said this request would “push [the department] a little bit.”

McMenimen’s other requests met more friction. McMenimen said she had not been sent the documents she needed to make a determination on the day’s case, such as physical plans and abutters’ notices, and met with resistance when she tried to get digital copies of them. She requested that the ZBA consider making it mandatory that all board members automatically receive a digital copy of all documents submitted on each case.

Sergi said all members should already be allowed to request any such documents, and other board members backed up the idea.

“I don’t know why we’re putting more on [administrative assistants’] plate, to send us a packet that I probably won’t look at,” said board member Matt Deveaux. “I have the case, I have the proposed finding of facts and the proposed decision … I don’t see why I need the paper trail.”

McMenimen also requested the board review and update its own internal regulations, which, according to the copy on the board’s webpage, were most recently updated in 2007. McMenimen pointed out that the rules require some sections, including the attached fee schedule, be reviewed every year.

Other board members were also initially surprised at the unexpected requests, and confused about how to respond to them. “It’s not that it’s not allowed, it just hasn’t been done,” said Sergi. McMenimen emphasized that all her requests had to be made during a public meeting in accordance with open meeting law.

In the end, the board agreed to rephrase the rest of McMenimen’s requests, asking Sergi to discuss all remaining topics with other city officials.

Author
A picture of Artie Kronenfeld.

Artie Kronenfeld is a Waltham-based reporter who enjoys writing about policy and administration that affect people’s everyday lives. Previously hailing from Toronto, they’re a former editor-in-chief of the University of Toronto’s flagship student paper The Varsity. You can find them during off-work hours playing niche RPGs, wandering through Haymarket and making extra spreadsheets that nobody asked for.

Comments (2)
  1. It is going to ruin the neighborhood and crime will go up. There is a house on my street that is illegal renting out now. Already had one drug overdose. I’m curious about the taxes on these ADUs. I’m paying a fortune for a shed.

  2. When Kathy McMenimen was a member of the City Council, she was vehemently against ADUs and any progressive housing initiatives. Now that she has been voted off the council she has been appointed as an associate member of the ZBA.
    I do hope that the ZBA members will be able to prevent her disrupting the workings of the ZBA and allow state law about ADUs to be implemented in a constructive and supportive manner.
    Waltham needs more affordable housing and ADUs can be a step in this direction.

Leave a comment

When commenting, please keep in mind we are a small non-profit focused on serving our community. Our commenting policy is simple:

  1. Common sense civility: we’re all neighbors, but we can disagree.
  2. Full name required: no anonymous comments.
  3. Assume the best of your neighbors.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Close the CTA